My Thoughts on First LA Dataportability Meetup

Dataportability LogoLast Friday was the first Dataportability meetup to take place in Los Angeles at the super cool new co-working location Blank Spaces. For those of you not familiar with the Dataportability movement here is the mission in their own words:

“To put all existing technologies and initiatives in context to create a reference design for end-to-end Data Portability. To promote that design to the developer, vendor and end-user community.”

Another quick way to understand the movement is to watch the short video below

DataPortability – Connect, Control, Share, Remix from Smashcut Media on Vimeo

The two principles heading up the discussion were Chris Saad & Ben Metcalfe. It began with everyone providing some details about who they were and why they were interested in Dataportability and what they wanted to get out of the discussion. After that it was pretty much an open forum to ask questions and discuss the movement in more detail.

One early question, and Chris confirmed this is one of the most common, is why would a vendor want to support Dataportability. It’s a very valid question, and one that can be a bit tricky to make a convincing case for. It’s basically a chicken / egg situation. I don’t believe a vendor will necessarily want to invest time and money opening and extending their architecture to accommodate Dataportability until their users and or outside pressure requires them to. Especially considering that most social service sites have an interest in protecting the content their users generate as it’s the valued asset they monetize through advertising and marketing. They may not necessarily want to see that data be free to live and or move to another service.

So based on that I feel an initial alternative route to take may be to make the case to end users. This can be a bit challenging as well because the case needs to be made in a very simple fashion. I feel that creating a hypothetical use case that is compelling to users and easy to grasp would be helpful. I’d love to see something along the lines of how Common Craft created the Twitter in plain english video.

What I’m proposing is they make a video targeted to the end user that is very specific in how this would work for them in the future. So let’s say hypothetically as an example that both Librarything & GoodReads (2 great services for managing your book reading) support DataPortability. Having spent countless hours adding over a hundred books to Librarything as well as reviewing, rating & tagging them, I decide I want to migrate to using the GoodReads service. The use case would provide the value in both saved time and flexibility showing the simple steps it would take to migrate the data from one Dataportability enabled service to the other.

I think overall Dataportability is an extremely important initiative based on solid existing standards. As a huge evangelist for Lifestreaming, I see the benefits pretty clearly. They’re also lucky to have some great PR going and talented technical people behind them. But it appears to me that much of the focus will need to be made on educating end users on its benefits and why they need it. This will then hopefully in turn put more pressure on vendors to adopt it.

Here’s a video from the event by TechZulu


Here’s a shot of Me and Don Mosites from
Mark Krynsky & Don Mosites from
photo courtesy of Lisa Brewster (user sophistechate on Flickr)

Lisa Brewster has posted many more photos from the event on Flickr here

6 thoughts on “My Thoughts on First LA Dataportability Meetup”

  1. Hey, just wanted to thank you for coming along to the Data Portability Meetup – it was great to meet you.

    Also thanks for the wonderful write up… I agree, educating users will be an important part of the task, and something we’ll begin to look closer at once we reach a tipping point with vendors. The timing has to be right, you see… educating users concludes with them being able to dive into something, so the vendors need to make something available for the user to be able to put the ideas into context… otherwise you hype them up and deliver nothing.

  2. Nice meeting you as well Ben and I wish you guys the best of luck. Hopefully you can get some pilot vendors going to show some proof of concept demonstrations. That would be another great step. I’m looking forward to the next meetup.

  3. Ambitious ? I don’t know. But really usefull…

    As example, I setup Terababy account with only one username on famous Web service which give me several of his usernames on another Web services which give several another usernames…
    Terababy LiFEstream (on LiFE2Front)

    NB: I advice LiFE2Front users to define their favorites 3rd party Web services on MyBlogLog and FriendFeed ;o)

    Today, several technologies allow me to apply DataPortability spirit without define new specification ; OPML, FOAF, Micro-Format, XFN, etc.

  4. Pingback: Choose your Lifestreaming Service Carefully. is No More | Lifestream Blog

Comments are closed.